Goalkeepers built for man-to-man
22 November 2026
Good morning!
|
|
Author of the Tactics Journal
|
In today’s email:
• Goalkeepers changed because the defensive phase changed
• You don’t have to hire out your thinking if you keep it simple
TACTICALLY INTERESTING
Teams and games I am following.
| Today | ||
| Barça | 13:00 | Villarreal |
| Santander | 15:15 | Real Sociedad |
| Liverpool | 16:30 | Man United |
| Yesterday | ||
| Real Madrid | 2-1 | Celta |
| Parma | 1-5 | Roma |
| Nice | 2-3 | PSG |
| Chelsea | 1-4 | Leeds United |
| M'gladbach | 0-1 | Dortmund |
| Como 1907 | 2-0 | Cagliari |
| Man City | 1-1 | Fulham |
- The Independent: Chelsea’s deep and ongoing issues revealed by Leeds drubbing
Chelsea 1-4 Leeds United: As the Blues drop to eighth in the table, Xabi Alonso must do more to address the lack of culture at the club - The Athletic: Rafael Nadal joins Real Madrid’s board of directors with 99.5 per cent member approval
The 22-time Grand Slam winner said it was "a great honour and a great source of satisfaction" to join Madrid's board. - The Athletic: Florentino Perez blasts ‘disgraceful’ La Liga boss Javier Tebas after Real Madrid, Nazi comparison
The president of La Liga previously compared Madrid’s communications tactics to those of former Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels.
Goalkeepers changed because the defensive phase changed
Tottenham Hotspur head coach Roberto De Zerbi:
The goalkeeper changed not for me, but the goalkeeper changed because the defensive phase changed. Because 20 years ago was maybe impossible to see one team defended man-to-man everywhere, every part of the pitch. If you defend man-to-man, there is just one player alone, and is the goalkeeper.
And then the rules of the goal kick changed, and changed the style of the goalkeeper.
First of all, the goalkeeper has to understand football, has to feel football and to think as a player. But in the same time he can’t forget to be a goalkeeper: the balance between to be one player more and to keep the goalkeeper mentality and the goalkeeper focus.
I still feel like the goakeeper position is one that could be improved. There is too much emphasis on how good a goalkeeper is passing or spotting a pass. And the goalkeepers have no choice but to get good at doing those things because there is not a lot of innovation going on further forward. As Roberto De Zerbi said, it is dependent on how the defensive phase changes.
POLL
When your team defends man-to-man across the pitch, how should your goalkeeper’s role change?
- Act as an extra outfield player
- Stay a traditional shot-stopper
- Balance both, prioritising goalkeeper focus
Tap a choice to vote. The result is shown on the page.
You don’t have to hire out your thinking if you keep it simple
Berkshire Hathaway vice chairman Charlie Munger speaking at the 1994 Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, answering a shareholder’s question about the long-term prospects of Nike and Reebo:
That is such an obvious point, and yet so many people think if they just hire somebody with the appropriate labels, they can do something very difficult. That is one of the most dangerous ideas a human being can have.
All kinds of things just intrinsically create problems. The other day I was dealing with a problem. It’s a new building, and I said, “This thing has three things I’ve learned to fear: an architect, a contractor, and a hill.”
And if you go at life like that, I think you at least make fewer mistakes than people who think they can do anything by just hiring somebody with a label.
You don’t have to hire out your thinking if you keep it simple.
The same thing can apply to hiring a manager. In the many many years of following this sport, I’ve yet to see a top team successfully hire from within. Everything is always outsourced. Multi-club ownership should change that.
| Sponsored by | |
Board The minimal tactics board that is yours. |
|
NEWS
- The Guardian: Teenager Williams-Barnett puts Tottenham on path to win over Ipswich
Not since the emergence of a certain Harry Kane has there been this much excitement about a player from Tottenham’s academy. - The Athletic: Manchester United’s Mauricio Pochettino payment to U.S. Soccer detailed in financial update
The club's Stock Market filing also covers the appointments of Jesus Perez, Miguel D’Agostino, Toni Jimenez and Sebastiano Pochettino.
RECOMMENDED READING
Everything published yesterday by the writers I follow
- Cavalry played centre-forward Tobias Warschewski on the left wing in the 2026 CPL Final
- Flamengo coach Leonardo Jardim only signs one-year contracts with a mutual option for a second year
- Allegri told McTominay to arrive behind Hojlund rather than start there
- Daring Fireball: ★ A Week With the New Privacy Controls in MacOS 27.3 Beta 2
- PSV coach Peter Bosz often doesn’t see who scores his team’s goals
- NEC stopped pressing the goalkeeper against PSV and left Matej Kovár on the ball
- Daring Fireball: The U.S. — Utterly Predictably — Has Lost Measles Elimination Status Under Trump and RFK Jr.
- Daring Fireball: Apple Documents Extra Apple Intelligence Usage Limits Per iCloud+ Paid Tier
- Marcelo Bielsa’s Marseille assistants showed players their runs on a computer during training
- Bayamón FC goalkeeper André Krul was handcuffed and flown home after his only match for the club
- The Bundesliga times how many seconds each team takes to win the ball back after losing it
- Lazio coach Gennaro Gattuso checks for late nights by watching players at a 9am team breakfast
2026
November
- 22nd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 16th
- 16th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 14th
- 13th
- 13th
- 12th
- 12th
- 12th
- 11th
- 11th
- 11th
- 11th
- 10th
- 10th
- 10th
- 10th
- 10th
- 9th
-
Older kids get picked for elite youth teams, but they don’t end up as the world’s best young players9th
- 9th
- 9th
- 9th
- 8th
- 8th
- 8th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 6th
- 6th
- 5th
- 5th
- 5th
- 5th
- 4th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
- 1st
October
- 31st
- 30th
- 30th
- 30th
- 29th
- 29th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 27th
- 27th
- 26th
- 26th
- 25th
- 25th
- 24th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 22nd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 21st
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 19th
- 18th
- 18th
- 18th
- 17th
- 17th
- 17th
- 17th
- 16th
- 16th
- 16th
- 16th
- 15th
- 15th
- 15th
- 14th
- 14th
- 13th
- 13th
- 13th
- 12th
- 12th
- 12th
- 11th
- 11th
- 11th
- 10th
- 10th
- 9th
- 9th
- 9th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 7th
- 6th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 3rd
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 2nd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
- 1st
September
- 30th
- 30th
- 29th
- 29th
- 29th
- 29th
- 28th
- 28th
- 28th
- 28th
- 27th
- 27th
- 27th
- 26th
- 26th
- 26th
- 26th
- 25th
- 25th
- 24th
- 24th
- 24th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 21st
- 21st
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 13th
- 12th
- 10th
- 8th
- 3rd
August
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 23rd
- 18th
- 16th
- 8th
- 8th
July
- 29th
- 27th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 17th
- 17th
- 16th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
June
- 30th
- 30th
- 29th
- 29th
- 29th
- 28th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 21st
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 15th
- 14th
- 14th
- 13th
- 13th
- 12th
- 12th
- 11th
- 11th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
May
- 31st
- 31st
- 30th
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
-
How analysts should measure whether high pressing is creating control or exposing transition attacks11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
March
- 24th
January
- 18th
2025
December
- 21st
- 16th
- 7th
- 3rd
November
- 29th
- 24th
- 20th
- 14th
- 12th
- 8th
- 7th
- 4th
- 2nd
October
- 31st
- 28th
- 22nd
- 20th
- 19th
- 12th
September
- 30th
- 28th
- 26th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 20th
- 18th
- 16th
- 14th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 1st
August
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 20th
- 17th
- 14th
- 12th
- 10th
- 8th
- 4th
July
- 10th
- 5th
- 4th
June
- 29th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 2nd
May
- 29th
- 25th
- 22nd
- 20th
- 15th
- 8th
April
- 30th
- 9th
March
- 28th
- 5th
February
- 26th
- 20th
- 19th
- 12th
- 8th
January
- 31st
- 30th
- 16th
- 12th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
2024
December
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
November
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 18th
- 16th
October
- 21st
- 12th
- 11th
- 9th
- 7th
- 6th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
September
- 30th
- 29th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
August
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
July
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
June
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
May
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
April
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
March
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 1st
February
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 18th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
January
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 25th
- 24th
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
2023
December
- 31st
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 25th
- 24th
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
November
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
October
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 19th
- 17th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 1st
September
- 30th
- 28th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 9th
- 3rd
August
- 31st
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 21st
- 20th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 7th
- 4th
- 3rd
July
- 31st
- 30th
- 28th
- 27th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
June
- 11th
- 10th
- 7th
- 5th
- 4th
- 1st
May
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
April
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 2nd
March
- 6th
February
- 27th
- 20th
- 5th
January
- 19th