The overlooked academy market

Good morning! Brilliant AMA yesterday if you missed it, give it a read.


TACTICALLY INTERESTING

Teams and games I am following.

  • The Guardian: PSG pummel Manchester City while Villa and Liverpool hit six: Football Weekly Extra – podcast
    Max Rushden is joined by Barry Glendenning , Nick Ames and Nicky Bandini as PSG thrash Manchester City in their first home game since the Premier League’s guilty verdict

São Paulo Head of Youth Scouting Luan Faria tracks players pushed down rival clubs’ queues

Luan Faria, Head of Youth Scouting at São Paulo, speaking to ge, describes São Paulo’s “meia confecção” strategy:

We target players who have already spent time developing at other clubs, particularly those with promising performance indicators and experience at major academies who were not given enough opportunities. Many can be brought in without a transfer fee. We identify their potential, take a chance on them, and the approach has produced results. […]

When I arrived, São Paulo did not have a proper market-analysis process. Players were often signed because someone had seen them in a single match, a coach liked them, or an executive thought they looked promising. There was no systematic evaluation designed to reduce recruitment mistakes. […]

We previously lacked the budget even to send scouts on routine trips. Information about players came from outside sources, often without enough evidence to evaluate it properly. Agents were constantly offering players of different standards, and decisions sometimes had to be made from videos lasting only half a minute. That created an enormous risk of mistakes. Today, when a player is offered, we already have detailed scouting reports that decision-makers can consult. […]

If you look at clubs with a financial advantage over us, their chance of error is very high because they are signing all the time. Players have ups and downs.

Flamengo made a move we could not compete with, but soon they sign another player and the boy who was a priority goes to the back of the queue. That is where we stay alert.

That was Djhordney’s case. Palmeiras got him, but they sign players every three months. He began to be left on the sidelines for several reasons. We began talking to his agent, found Palmeiras would not exercise the purchase option, and went to Novorizontino to arrange a loan.

Share · Comment


POLL

Should your academy recruit players overlooked by rival clubs’ development pathways?

Tap a choice to vote. The result is shown on the page.



NEWS

  • The Athletic: Former Everton bidder Josh Wander, 777 Partners co-founder, pleads guilty to fraud charges
    The 45-year-old pleaded guilty to wire and securities fraud charges — each of which carries a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison.
  • The Guardian: Martínez apologises to Manchester United’s director of football Wilcox after outburst
    Defender says sorry after talks with Michael Carrick
  • The Athletic: Lisandro Martinez apologises for Manchester United criticism after ‘very positive’ club meeting
    The 28-year-old met with the club's leadership on Thursday after saying he "expected more" from United's technical director, Jason Wilcox.

RECOMMENDED READING

Everything published yesterday by the writers I follow

2026

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

March

January

2025

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

2024

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

2023

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January