Let Wirtz roam

Good morning! I made a horrible choice to watch United vs. Aletico yesterday. Have to watch back at least one of the other matches.

In today’s email:

• Lisandro Martinez goes after the technial director
• The Wirtz-situation is a train wreck


TACTICALLY INTERESTING

Teams and games I am following.

  • The Athletic: Lisandro Martinez attacks Man United investment, squad: ‘I expect more from our technical director’
    The Argentina international said that the 2-0 Champions League loss to Atletico Madrid was a "mirror for the club".
  • The Athletic: Vinicius Jr’s struggle for Real Madrid form ‘breaks my heart’, says Jose Mourinho
    The 26-year-old Brazil international has scored just one goal for Real Madrid in nine appearances this season.

Lisandro Martinez goes after the technial director

Manchester United defender (in this case attacker?), Lisandro Martinez, after their 2-0 defeat to Atletico Madrid:

Interviewer: A tough result. First of all, how do you sum up the performance?

Lisandro Martinez: Really poor. Really poor. I have to control myself a lot. But sometimes it’s a reflection, the mirror, of how our club is at the moment. We had a fantastic season last season, and now we expected more from the top, from up, to bring more players to compete, because many teams bring in many players as well. And today Atletico also have an amazing team, and they deserve to win today.

Interviewer: So this is not a Champions League quality squad? But what you’re saying is you expected more investment in the squad in the summer?

Lisandro Martinez: Yeah, 100%. I speak more about our technical director. I have to be honest, you know. And also, as the players, we have to do more. But it’s important to make a strong squad, to be ready for this kind of night.

Interviewer: In which areas? In defense? In attack? Because obviously there was money invested in midfield.

Lisandro Martinez: In general. In general. Last season we did everything. We created a base to build an amazing team. But this is something to be honest about, and to prove something, you know. Yeah, it’s annoying. It’s disappointing coming here and not seeing my team trying to get an amazing result here. It’s disappointing.

Interviewer: The manager, of course, gets a lot of criticism. Is the problem that the manager wasn’t backed enough in the summer in terms of investment?

Lisandro Martinez: I don’t think so. I don’t think so. He does his best. But every season is different. You can’t stay with what you did last season. The teams know how you play. The teams know every detail, you know. And if you don’t change, next season it’s a big problem.

Very rare to hear talks about a technical director from a player. Is it warranted? I don’t know.

I am not a fan of Andrey Santos. Carlos Baleba is of the same vein as Casemiro, but he doesn’t have the same level of intelligance that Casemiro had, yet. I like that they are going for players with Premier League expierence like Youri Tielemans. United teams of the past lacked that experience.

I don’t think they needed another Sesko, Cunha, Mbeumo level window but they made moves this summer for the future. They obviously are not in a position to win now.

It would make more sense to rebuild as Bruno Fernandes begins to age. You aren’t going to build around him when he is 32 years old.

Share · Comment


The Wirtz-situation is a train wreck

Martin Rafelt:

The Wirtz-situation is a train wreck. It’s a mixture of wrong expectations, incorrect role and playstyle, resulting confidence issues.

And, tragically, it looks as if his teammates don’t want to play with him.

None of these are mega bad, but they’re adding up.

Point 1, Expectations & Role: Wirtz is no 150M-player as an INDIVIDUAL creator. He is not an elite athlete. He is nimble, quick and can run, but he is not going to demolish PL-defenders in open space.

He is absolutely astonishing as a team player. He has an unusual profile.

He can create from literally anywhere. And he is amazing in picking when to appear where. At Leverkusen he moved from wing to wing, FB, DMF, half-spaces, attacking center.

Pin him to a definitive position and you lose a big deal of what makes him special. Let him float.

He is amazing in finding advantages on the pitch, but he also NEEDS advantages. Put him in a strict position within a non- or semi-functional team and he needs to create from neutral, balanced and predictable situations. He will be okay doing that, but far away from 150M.

I feel like this is the case for many players in today’s game. Wirtz just happened to be a player who was afforded those opportunities to float when he played for Bayer Leverkusen.

Although he is not as creative as Wirtz, this makes you appreciate what Phil Foden has been able to accomplish in the Premier League. Maybe he would be as creative if he was used to floating. He is also a very unusual profile, but a very moldable player. Wirtz doesn’t seem to be as moldable.

What I mean by moldable is that if you asked Foden ‘in order to progress the ball forward, you have to perform one rainbow flick per posession.’ I feel like Foden would be able to do it, and do it quickly. I don’t think Wirtz would be able to do that. And he doesn’t have to be worth the money.

Share · Comment


POLL

Should Wirtz be given freedom to move across the pitch rather than a fixed creator role?

Tap a choice to vote. The result is shown on the page.



NEWS

  • The Athletic: David Ornstein’s The Athletic FC Q&A: Arsenal’s transfer decisions? How secure is Michael Carrick?
    David Ornstein has been answering reader questions on his weekly The Athletic FC podcast
  • The Guardian: ‘I expect more’: Lisandro Martínez hits out at Manchester United hierarchy
    - Defeat to Atlético Madrid ‘reflects how our club is’ - Argentinian says club has not invested enough in players
  • The Guardian: Barrios strikes after 53 seconds as Atlético pile misery on 10-man Manchester United
    Michael Carrick had seen it in his players, he said, but no one else can.
  • The Guardian: Timber’s touch of class and supersub Saka secure Arsenal win against Lille
    Twelve wins in a row and counting.
  • The Guardian: Patrice Motsepe’s Caf presidency under pressure after Afcon U-turn as Eto’o waits in wings
    Rivals lining up to position as potential replacements
  • The Guardian: Maresca says he would describe Manchester City as ‘cheats’ if he was a United fan
    Manager claims City fans suffering more than players

RECOMMENDED READING

Everything published yesterday by the writers I follow

2026

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

March

January

2025

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

2024

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

2023

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January