AMA with Carlon Carpenter
22 October 2026
Good morning! We have an AMA today with Carlon Carpenter! Also, why did Bayern look so lethargic?
|
|
Author of the Tactics Journal
|
In today’s email:
• AMA with Carlon Carpenter
• USL Unveils New Brand Identity Ahead of 2028 Three-Tier Promotion and Relegation System
• Erik ten Hag on Man United: ‘The team was not consistent’
TACTICALLY INTERESTING
Teams and games I am following.
| Yesterday | ||
| Bayern | 2-2 | Arsenal |
| Real Madrid | 4-1 | RB Leipzig |
| Como 1907 | 4-1 | Man United |
- The Guardian: ‘It doesn’t look good’: Arteta concerned as Saka limps off against Bayern Munich
- ‘A player off with really sharp pain is never good news’ - Winger forced off 10 minutes into Arsenal’s 2-2 draw - The Guardian: Arsenal’s Declan Rice strikes late to deny Bayern Munich after Harry Kane penalty
It is as if Harry Kane cannot get enough of tormenting Arsenal.

AMA with Carlon Carpenter
Lead Performance Analyst at Manchester United Women, Carlon Carpenter, is taking questions now for an AMA about performance analysis and tactics.
USL Unveils New Brand Identity Ahead of 2028 Three-Tier Promotion and Relegation System
USL:
The rebrand comes as the USL prepares to reshape its men’s professional league structure. Beginning in 2028, USL Premier will serve as the top level of a three-tier system alongside the USL Championship and USL League One, with promotion and relegation allowing clubs to move between divisions based on performance.
Developed in partnership with creative agency Spark, the new identity draws inspiration from soccer itself, incorporating elements of the ball, field and goal nets into a visual system that connects the USL’s leagues, clubs and communities. The identity also introduces a unified USL Blue and updated league marks featuring a shared design inspired by woven goal nets. Together, the eight marks, including USL Premier, form a cohesive, recognizable family of brands
I am rooting for the USL. I do not like the MLS’ structure with no promotion or relegation, even if they have the money, sponsors, and bigger names.
Erik ten Hag on Man United: ‘The team was not consistent’
Former Manchester United manager, Erik ten Hag, interviewed by Laurie Whitwell for The Atheltic:
“The team was not consistent,” says Ten Hag. “On our good day we could match the best teams in the league, in the world, I would even say. On the worst day, we sat below the bottom. And then in Liverpool, obviously, we went below the bottom, also mentality-wise. It was the next Premier League game after we won the League Cup. We were on the high; we went up there, maybe we were too confident, and we got punished. Every attack was a goal.”
But the game in which Ten Hag feels his reign changed was the quarter-final of the Europa League a month later, when United were knocked out 5-2 on aggregate by Sevilla, having been 2-0 up in the first leg. “The team couldn’t play without two players,” he says, naming Lisandro Martinez (Licha) and Bruno Fernandes.
“Licha was so important for us to play from the back, but also the winning mentality, winning duels. And Bruno. In that game (first leg), at 2-0 up, I decided to sub Bruno, 30 minutes from time, and then Lisandro broke his foot.”
Lisandro Martinez played 20 of 63 competitive matches when Ruben Amorim was manager.
This may surprise you but I watched every Manchester United match under Amorim.
With Andre Onana in goal, who cost them small games and big games, they desperately needed actual center-backs other than Matthijs De Ligt.
POLL
After a trophy win, should coaches prioritize managing confidence before the next league match?
Tap a choice to vote. The result is shown on the page.
| Sponsored by | |
Board The minimal tactics board that is yours. |
|
NEWS
- The Guardian: ‘Angry’ Carrick on the brink as Fernandes hits out at Manchester United tactics
- Manager apologises to fans after 4-1 defeat in Como - Captain criticises ‘decision from the staff’ not to press - The Guardian: Barkley and Buendía on target as Aston Villa sink Viking to maintain perfect start
For a little over 20 minutes, Aston Villa could look down on the rest of Europe. - The Guardian: Paris Saint-Germain sparkle on the pitch while the city of light burns around them
PSG, pet project of the state of Qatar, expresses the dualism of the city, a place of deprivation where the centre is perfect - The Guardian: Carrick under more pressure as Manchester United humbled against Como
In the shadow of the Alps, a boat ride from George Clooney’s villa, Manchester United’s torrid season plunged into chaos and infighting just 11 games in. - Pol Ballús - The Athletic: Barcelona’s Dani Olmo to miss El Clasico, expected to be out for a month
In a statement, Barca said tests had revealed an injury to Olmo's left adductor muscle and he would be out of action for "around a month".
RECOMMENDED READING
Everything published yesterday by the writers I follow
- Bayern Munich coach Vincent Kompany publicly names mistakes, then backs players
Kompany names individual mistakes in the media and points players to their responsibilities. - Napoli winger Matteo Politano uses six steps to meet the cross
Napoli winger Matteo Politano first runs inward toward goal, pressing his marker back. - Osijek player Izak Ježić is the youngest player with 300 league minutes in CIES’s sample
- FC Twente technical director Erik ten Hag ranks technical skill first in player assessment
FC Twente technical director Erik ten Hag says he assesses players against seven points. - Boca Juniors targeted Vasco midfielder Santiago Sosa in buildup
Boca Juniors pressed Vasco midfielder Santiago Sosa in buildup.
2026
November
- 15th
- 14th
- 14th
- 13th
- 13th
- 12th
- 12th
- 12th
- 11th
- 11th
- 11th
- 11th
- 10th
- 10th
- 10th
- 10th
- 10th
- 9th
-
Older kids get picked for elite youth teams, but they don’t end up as the world’s best young players9th
- 9th
- 9th
- 9th
- 8th
- 8th
- 8th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 7th
- 6th
- 6th
- 5th
- 5th
- 5th
- 5th
- 4th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
- 1st
October
- 31st
- 30th
- 30th
- 30th
- 29th
- 29th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 27th
- 27th
- 26th
- 26th
- 25th
- 25th
- 24th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 22nd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 21st
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 19th
- 18th
- 18th
- 18th
- 17th
- 17th
- 17th
- 17th
- 16th
- 16th
- 16th
- 16th
- 15th
- 15th
- 15th
- 14th
- 14th
- 13th
- 13th
- 13th
- 12th
- 12th
- 12th
- 11th
- 11th
- 11th
- 10th
- 10th
- 9th
- 9th
- 9th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 7th
- 6th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 3rd
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 2nd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
- 1st
September
- 30th
- 30th
- 29th
- 29th
- 29th
- 29th
- 28th
- 28th
- 28th
- 28th
- 27th
- 27th
- 27th
- 26th
- 26th
- 26th
- 26th
- 25th
- 25th
- 24th
- 24th
- 24th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 21st
- 21st
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 13th
- 12th
- 10th
- 8th
- 3rd
August
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 23rd
- 18th
- 16th
- 8th
- 8th
July
- 29th
- 27th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 17th
- 17th
- 16th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
June
- 30th
- 30th
- 29th
- 29th
- 29th
- 28th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 21st
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 15th
- 14th
- 14th
- 13th
- 13th
- 12th
- 12th
- 11th
- 11th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
May
- 31st
- 31st
- 30th
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
-
How analysts should measure whether high pressing is creating control or exposing transition attacks11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
- 1st
March
- 24th
January
- 18th
2025
December
- 21st
- 16th
- 7th
- 3rd
November
- 29th
- 24th
- 20th
- 14th
- 12th
- 8th
- 7th
- 4th
- 2nd
October
- 31st
- 28th
- 22nd
- 20th
- 19th
- 12th
September
- 30th
- 28th
- 26th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 20th
- 18th
- 16th
- 14th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 1st
August
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 20th
- 17th
- 14th
- 12th
- 10th
- 8th
- 4th
July
- 10th
- 5th
- 4th
June
- 29th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 2nd
May
- 29th
- 25th
- 22nd
- 20th
- 15th
- 8th
April
- 30th
- 9th
March
- 28th
- 5th
February
- 26th
- 20th
- 19th
- 12th
- 8th
January
- 31st
- 30th
- 16th
- 12th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
2024
December
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
November
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 18th
- 16th
October
- 21st
- 12th
- 11th
- 9th
- 7th
- 6th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
September
- 30th
- 29th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
August
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
July
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
June
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
May
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
April
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
March
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 1st
February
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 18th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
January
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 25th
- 24th
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
2023
December
- 31st
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 25th
- 24th
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
November
- 30th
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
October
- 31st
- 30th
- 29th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 19th
- 17th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 1st
September
- 30th
- 28th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 9th
- 3rd
August
- 31st
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 21st
- 20th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 7th
- 4th
- 3rd
July
- 31st
- 30th
- 28th
- 27th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 12th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 6th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
June
- 11th
- 10th
- 7th
- 5th
- 4th
- 1st
May
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 19th
- 18th
- 17th
- 16th
- 15th
- 14th
- 13th
- 11th
- 10th
- 9th
- 8th
- 7th
- 5th
- 4th
- 3rd
- 2nd
- 1st
April
- 29th
- 28th
- 27th
- 26th
- 25th
- 24th
- 23rd
- 22nd
- 22nd
- 21st
- 20th
- 2nd
March
- 6th
February
- 27th
- 20th
- 5th
January
- 19th