---
title: "What game situation is this actually recreating"
date: 2026-09-28T17:43:36-04:00
categories: ["opinion"]
url: https://tacticsjournal.com/2026/09/28/what-game-situation-is-this-actually-recreating/
---

# What game situation is this actually recreating

[David Garcia:](https://x.com/IJaSport/status/2104670161315749942?s=20)

> One of the strangest things about football training is how many activities have become completely detached from the game situations they were originally designed to solve.
>
> Take something like a 4v4+3, you can find thousands of versions online, coaches use it everywhere, it looks recognizably “football,” players are busy, there are decisions, pressure, passing, support, all the things we associate with a good activity, but ask a really basic question, what game situation is this actually recreating, and what problem are the players meant to become better at solving?, and quite often there isn’t a clear answer.
>
> I don’t think that means the activity is bad, I think it means we’ve often started at the wrong end.
>
> An activity gets created because a coach sees something happening repeatedly in a match, they want their players to experience that situation more often, so they build a training environment around it, but then the activity gets shared, copied, modified, put into session libraries, posted online, copied again, and eventually the original game problem disappears.
>
> What remains is the exercise.

Crafting training sessions around the match seems like common sense.

---

Previous post: [If WAR works for hockey, it can work in football](https://tacticsjournal.com/2026/09/28/if-war-works-for-hockey-it-can-work-in-football.md)

Next post: [Train the game problem](https://tacticsjournal.com/morning/2026/09/29.md)

---

Web page: https://tacticsjournal.com/2026/09/28/what-game-situation-is-this-actually-recreating/
Every post and page as Markdown: https://tacticsjournal.com/llms.txt
